Bloodletting (Who would win in a fight ? #6)

Bill "The Butcher" Vs. Al Swearengen (Deadwood)

Created By:
chrisvalls
chrisvalls
Date Created: 01.14.08

Bill "The Butcher" Cutting

Based on real life Bower Boys gangleader, Bill Poole.

Bill
VS

Al Swearengen (Deadwood)

as portrayed by Ian McShane. real life, Born 7-8-1845, Died 1904.

Al Swearengen (Deadwood)

This Battle:

84%
VS
16%

Total Votes

43

Comments [4]

nickkasack

Bill Poole was a bare knuckle boxer, and as Bill Cutting, as i know from deadwood beat his wofe, and Bill Cutting would not accept that. Sure, Al may of been a pimp and had the ladies, but Bill would probably beat him like he did the bartender at the Florence Hotel in 1850 or 51, i cant remember. If i am wrong and i got my history incorrect, i aplogize, but i think i am right.

This is why i go for Bill Poole.

 
chrisvalls

please leave an explanation for your decision.
I'm dying to see these results.